The influence of Law on Medical Practice
(Portuguese PDF version)
Coordinator: Ricardo C. R. Moreira

Moacir Assein Arus*

*MD. Vice-President of Hospital de Clínicas de Porto Alegre. Associate professor, Department of Psychiatry and Forensic Medicine, School of Medicine, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil.

J Vasc Br 2004;3(2):176


"A influência do Direito no exercício da Medicina" ("The influence of Law on Medical practice"), by professor Jorge R. Ribas Timi and collaborators, deserves to be on the shelf of every doctor and medical student.

Professor Timi and the other authors approach, in a simple, direct and concise way, the ethical, penal and civil responsibilities of doctors. They also address topics regarding rights of patient, informed consent, medical secrecy, medical investigation, autonomy of terminal patients and other specific subjects, providing a light and attractive reading. The authors managed to involve the reader in a way that one cannot wait to finish a chapter to start the next one and soon go back to the previous chapter to review a concept.

The authors provide the reader with up-to-date information, practical examples, and even real cases that have already been on court.

Sometimes, reading citations from the Code of Medical Ethics or the Penal, Civil and Consumer Code may be rather boring for doctors, who are not used to the juridical discourse. In this book, these citations are conveniently integrated within the text so that they will be easily assimilated.

Through the popular question-and-answer format, the authors were sensible enough to address some aspects that frequently make doctors anxious and insecure:

  • How to behave if I am required to give evidence as witness in a case involving a patient?

  • What to do in face of procedures that are not covered by the Health System?

  • Is the electronic medical record safe?
Polemic and including issues, such as blood transfusion in Jehovah's Witness patient and euthanasia are also addressed.

This book focuses on the need of doctors to be aware of legal aspects regarding the exercise of medicine and emphasizes the importance of a good relationship between patient and doctor in order to avoid legal suit, having the Code of Medical Ethics as "the cornerstone for the correct practice of Medicine"

Undoubtedly, the authors managed to achieve their goal: to contribute to the understanding of important issues which reside in the interface of Medicine and Law.

It is everyday reading!

As vascular surgeon and professor of Forensic Medicine and Medical Deontology, I would like to thank professor Timi and his collaborators for this work. I am sure it will be very useful!

J Vasc Br - Official Publication of the Brazilian Society of Angiology and Vascular Surgery