
Iliac
artery lesions as experimental models of vascular trauma inducing intraperitoneal
and retroperitonial hemorrhage
(PDF
version)
Luiz
Francisco Poli de Figueiredo1, Ruy Jorge Cruz Jr.2,
Victor Bruscagin3, Samir Rasslan3,
Maurício Rocha e Silva2
Supported
by Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de
São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil (bolsa FAPESP 98/15658-0).
1.
Applied Physiology Service, Instituto do Coração/Faculdade
de Medicina da USP (InCor/FMUSP). Dept. of Surgery, Universidade Federal
de São Paulo/Escola Paulista de Medicina (UNIFESP/EPM).
2. Applied Physiology Service, InCor/FMUSP.
3. Emergency Service, Dept. of Surgery, Faculdade
de Ciências Médicas da Santa Casa de São Paulo.
Correspondence:
Luiz F. Poli de Figueiredo
Av. Enéas de Carvalho Aguiar, 44
CEP 05403-000 - São Paulo - SP
Fax: (11) 3068.9955 - Phone: (11) 3069.5297
E-mail: lpoli@uol.com.br
ABSTRACT
Objective:
The initial treatment of uncontrolled hemorrhage is controversial.
Therefore, the objective of this study was to develop an experimental
model of retroperitoneal hemorrhage, induced by an iliac artery
puncture through the femoral artery, to evaluate its hemodynamic
and metabolic consequences and to correlate them with the blood
loss volume, measured by radioisotopes.
Method:
We designed two experimental models of uncontrolled hemorrhage
induced by an intraperitoneal and a retroperitoneal iliac artery
lesions in dogs (17.1±0.56 kg). In the first set of experiments,
a suture was placed through the common iliac artery to produce a
3 mm tear, when the external suture lines were pulled after incision
closure, to induce an intraperitoneal hemorrhage. After 20 minutes,
the animals were randomized to controls (CT, n=6, no fluids) or
to lactated Ringerís (LR, 32 mL/kg in 15 min, n=6). Intraabdominal
blood loss volume was directly measured 40 minutes after the iliac
artery tear. In another set of experiments, dogs were randomized
to unilateral (UL, n=11) or bilateral (BL, n=11) iliac artery puncture,
using a metallic device introduced through the femoral arteries
and followed for 120 minutes. Initial and final blood volumes were
determined using radioactive tracers, 99mTC and 51Cr,
respectively.
Results:
In the first set of experiments, all animals presented acute fall
in arterial pressure and cardiac output. CT animals remained with
severe hypotension and low flows, while LR showed transient improvements
in arterial pressure and cardiac output, without promoting significant
increases in blood loss volume (CT 47.8±5.9 vs. RL 49.4±0.7,
in mL/kg). In the second set of experiments, UL was associated with
a stable arterial pressure and a moderate decrease in cardiac output
and oxygen delivery. BL induced an abrupt and sustained decrease
in mean arterial pressure and a much greater reduction in cardiac
output, oxygen delivery and consumption. Retroperitoneal blood loss
after BL was 36.8±3.2 ml/kg, while after UL was 25.1±3.4
ml/kg (P=0.0262).
Conclusions:
Bilateral iliac artery puncture produces hypotension and low flow
state, while a unilateral iliac artery lesion causes a compensated
shock state. Both the anterior iliac tear or posterior iliac puncture
showed to be clinically relevant models of vascular trauma, inducing
uncontrolled intraperitoneal and retroperitoneal hemorrhages, respectively.
Key
words: resuscitation; iliac artery; hemorrhage; shock
Palavras-chave: ressuscitação, artéria
ilíaca, hemorragia, choque.
J
Vasc Br 2002;1(1):39-46.
INTRODUCTION
Clinically
relevant models of vascular trauma are needed for studies addressing
controversies on trauma research and new surgical strategies. Currently,
one of the greatest controversies is the prehospital and emergency room
approach of hypotensive trauma victims sustaining injuries which could
result in uncontrolled hemorrhage. Volume resuscitation has been the
mainstay treatment of these patients1. However,
this approach has been challenged by several authors, based on experimental
studies2,3,4
which suggests that fluid infusion, prior to the control of bleeding,
may result in increased blood loss. Additionally, a controversial clinical
study suggested that delayed fluid resuscitation is associated with
better outcome for penetrating torso hypotensive victims.5
These studies hypothesized that fluid infusion, before hemorrhage control,
would enhance bleeding through several mechanisms, such as increased
blood pressure, which would dislodge blood clots, and the dilution of
clotting factors. The highest risk for bleeding was considered for patients
sustaining penetrating abdominal vascular trauma. To address the controversy
on whether fluid infusion increases bleeding, we directly measured intra-abdominal
blood loss in animals sustaining uncontrolled hemorrhage after an iliac
artery tear.6
Uncontrolled
retroperitoneal hemorrhage, as induced by pelvic fractures, may result
in hypovolemic shock and fluid resuscitation is the cornerstone therapeutic
approach, associated with external fixation, in selected cases.7-10
Whether fluid resuscitation increases retroperitoneal uncontrolled hemorrhage
is not known. Clinically relevant models of retroperitoneal hematoma
are lacking. The only experimental model of retroperitoneal hemorrhage
that we are aware of was described by Baylis in 1962, produced by an
injection of venous blood, collected through the femoral vein, into
the retroperitoneal space.11
We developed an experimental model of retroperitoneal hemorrhage, induced
by an iliac artery puncture through the femoral artery, to evaluate
its hemodynamic and metabolic consequences and to correlate them with
the blood loss volume, measured by radioisotopes.12
We present
both experimental models of iliac artery trauma which could be suitable
for several studies including fluid resuscitation, coagulation, shock
and new surgical approaches such as endovascular and videolaparoscopic
surgeries.
MATERIAL
AND METHODS
The experimental
protocols were approved by the Institutional Review Board of the Heart
Institute (InCor), University of São Paulo, in adherence with
the "Principles of Laboratory Animal Care" formulated by the
National Society for Medical Research and the "Guide for the Care
and Use of Animals" by the National Institutes of Health.
Animal
preparation
These studies
were performed using 48 male mongrel dogs, weighing 17±1.5 kg.
Dogs were fasted for 12 hours before the study, with free access to
water. Anesthesia was induced with an intravenous injection of sodium
pentobarbital, 25 mg/kg. After endotracheal intubation, the animals
were allowed to breathe spontaneously, with no supplemental oxygen,
throughout the experiment. Additional doses of pentobarbital, 2 mg/kg,
were used whenever required.
The right
common femoral artery was dissected and cannulated with a polyethylene
cannula to measure mean arterial pressure at the abdominal aorta and
to collect arterial blood samples for blood gas, pH, bicarbonate, base
excess, hemoglobin and plasma sodium analysis. The right common femoral
vein was cannulated in a similar fashion for fluid infusion. An 7 Fr
flow-directed pulmonary artery catheter (93A-131H-7F, Edwards Swan-Ganz,
Baxter Edwards Critical Care, Irvine, CA) was introduced through the
right external jugular vein and its tip placed in the pulmonary artery,
guided by pressure and wave tracings. This catheter was used to sample
mixed venous blood for blood gas analysis and to measure pulmonary arterial
pressure and cardiac output (Edwards COM-2 Cardiac Output Computer,
Baxter Edwards Critical Care, Irvine, CA). Cardiac output was measured
intermittently by the thermodilution technique in triplicate, with 3-mL
bolus injections of isotonic saline at 20ºC every ten minutes.
All pressure measuring catheters were connected to pressure transducers
and then to a Biopac Data Acquisition System (Model MP100, Biopac Systems,
Goleta, CA) or to a galvanometric recorder (model 7700 Hewlett-Packard,
San Diego, CA) for continuous recording of heart rate, systemic arterial
and pulmonary artery pressures and waveforms. Arterial and venous blood
samples were analyzed by a Stat Profile Ultra Analyzer (Nova Biomedical,
Waltham, MA).
Iliac
artery tear for intraabdominal hemorrhage (n = 20)
A six-centimeter,
pararetal longitudinal incision was then performed at the left lower
quadrant. After celiotomy, bowel loops were displaced medially. The
left common iliac artery was identified and dissected for about one
centimeter. A 3-0 polypropylene suture was passed through the anterior
portion of the artery, exit points 3 mm apart, in order to produce a
3 mm arterial tear at the appropriate experimental moment. The extremities
of the suture lines were exteriorized through the incision, which was
closed by planes for airtightness of the abdominal cavity.
After the
surgical preparation, animals were placed on their left side and allowed
to stabilize. Baseline measurements were obtained and an uncontrolled,
intra-abdominal hemorrhage was induced by pulling out both extremities
of the exteriorized suture lines. The animals were allowed to bleed
for 20 minutes, after which survivors were randomly assigned to three
experimental groups: CT (n = 6), control group, received no fluid or
LR (n=6), lactated Ringer's, 32 ml/kg injected over a 15-minute period.
Forty minutes after the induction of uncontrolled hemorrhage, the animals
were euthanized by an anesthetic overdose followed by a saturated KCl
injection. A xifopubic median laparotomy was rapidly performed, the
left iliac artery was clamped, and all intra-abdominal blood loss was
directly measured by weighing all clots and free blood. The iliac artery
was then resected, opened longitudinally, and the size of the iliac
artery tear was measured using a precision pachymeter.
Heart rate,
mean systemic and pulmonary arterial pressures were continuously recorded.
Intermittent cardiac output (CO) was measured at 5 minute intervals
and expressed as cardiac index [CO / body surface area (BSA= 0.112*weight2/3)].
Hemodynamic data were analyzed at baseline, and every five minute interval
thereafter. Mixed venous oxygen saturation (SvO2) and arterial
base excess, oxygen tension, oxygen saturation, bicarbonate and hemoglobin
levels were measured at 0, 20, 30 and 40 minutes. Oxygen delivery was
calculated using standard formulae.
Iliac
artery puncture for retroperitoneal hemorrhage (n=22)
Both common
femoral arteries were dissected and prepared to be cannulated to induce
the uncontrolled retroperitoneal hemorrhage at the appropriate timepoint.
To produce reproducible unilateral or bilateral iliac arterial lesions,
we adapted a standard radio antenna, which is a stainless steel hollow
tube and a solid, blunt-ended stainless steel shaft, which was introduced
through both common femoral arteries. Uncontrolled retroperitoneal hemorrhage
was produced by driving the shaft forward and immediately retracting
it back, inducing a 2 mm lesion in the posterior aspect of the iliac
artery, thereby avoiding an intraperitoneal hemorrhage, which was associated,
in pilot studies, with massive blood loss and rapid death in four dogs.
Thirty
minutes after completion of surgical preparation, baseline measurements
were obtained (0 min). With both femoral arteries catheterized with
our device, the animals were then randomized for UL (n=11), unilateral
lesion, at the right iliac artery or BL (n=11), bilateral lesions,
at the right and left iliac arteries. After 120 minutes from induction
of hemorrhage, the animals were euthanized by an anesthesia overdose
and saturated KCl infusion. A celiotomy was then performed to observe
the presence and the extension of the retroperitoneal hematoma, and
the presence or absence of blood within the peritoneal cavity.
Heart rate
and both mean systemic and pulmonary arterial pressures were monitored
continuously throughout the experiment. Cardiac output was measured
at 10 minute intervals. Arterial and venous hematocrit, hemoglobin,
base deficit, oxygen saturation and oxygen tension were measured at
0, 10, 60 and 120 minutes. Oxygen delivery, oxygen consumption and cardiac
index were calculated using standard formulae.
Red blood
cell and blood volumes were determined by isotope dilution technique
of two radioactive tracers, technetium (99mTC) and chromium
(51Cr), according to the KOWALSKY and PERRY guidelines.13
A volume of 3 mL of blood was collected through the left jugular vein
and labeled with technetium (99mTc - TCK-11, CIS Bio International,
France), which has a half life of six hours. The concentration of radioactive
red blood cells (TLi = injected total load, in counts/min/mL)
was determined using a well-type scintillation counter (Phillips Medical
System Division XL1100, Eindhoven, Nederlands). These marked red cells
were returned through the left jugular vein and a 15 minute interval
was observed to allow for a homogeneous distribution of the radiotracer.
Another 7 mL blood sample was collected through the pulmonary artery
catheter and the concentration of the radiotracer (TLc = collected
total load, in counts/min/mL) was determined. Baseline red cell blood
volume (RCVb, in mL/kg) was estimated by the dilution technique
of marked red cells, by the following formula: [RCVb = TLi
/ TLc]. Fifteen minutes, before the end of the experiment, the
final red blood cell volume (RCVf) was determined, using a similar
technique as described above; however, chromium (51Cr, Instituto
de Pesquisas de Energia Nuclear-IPEN/CNEN, São Paulo, Brazil)
was used to label the red cells. Baseline and final blood volumes (BVb
and BVf, respectively) were estimated through the respective
red cell volume and the corrected hematocrit: [BVb,f =RCV
b,f / 0.96 x Ht]. The volume of red cells in the hematoma
(RCVh) was estimated as the difference between baseline and final
red cell volume (RCVh = RCVb -RCVf), while the
blood volume (BVh) in the hematoma was calculated from RCVh
and the initial hematocrit: [BVh = RCVh / 0.96 x Ht].
RESULTS
Iliac
artery tear for intraabdominal hemorrhage (n = 20)
At baseline
all animals were stable (Fig 1, Table 1). The size of the arterial tear
was very similar between groups (in mm, CT 2.4±0.4; LR 2.3±0.2).
Total intra-abdominal blood loss, measured at the end of the experiments,
was not significantly different between CT (47.8±5.9 mL/kg) and
LR (49.4±0.7 mL/kg).
Figure
1 - Mean arterial pressure (in mmHg)
and cardiac index (in L/min/m2, mean ± SEM), during 40 min of
uncontrolled intraabdominal hemorrhage from an iliac artery tear for
groups CT (no fluids, n=6), and LR (32 mL/kg in 15 min, n=6).

Table
1 - Oxygen delivery, mixed venous oxygen saturation, hemoglobin and
arterial pH, bicarbonate and base excess levels (mean ± SEM)
during 40 min of uncontrolled intraabdominal hemorrhage from an iliac
artery tear for groups CT (no fluids, n=6) and LR (32 mL/kg in 15 min,
n=6)
 |
|
|
Group
|
Basal
|
20-minute
|
30-minute
|
40-minute
|
 |
|
O2
delivery
mLO2/min
|
CT
LR
|
494±89.2
366±35.4
|
93±25.3
97±43.4
a
|
83±22.4
234±110.1
|
85±20.8
199±78.5
|
|
SVO2
%
|
CT
LR
|
73.5±3.1
72.6±3.25
|
39.8±8.4
44.0±15.1
|
32.5±9.2
55.8±7.4
|
27.1±9.1
46.1±14.2
|
|
Hemoglobin
g/dl
|
CT
LR
|
12.6±0.5
12.3±0.5
|
14.0±0.5
12.3±0.6
|
13.2±0.7
8.1±0.5
|
13.4±0.5
7.2±0.7
|
|
pH
|
CT
LR
|
7.32±0.02
7.36±0.01
|
7.28±0.02
7.29±0.01
|
7.26±0.03
7.23±0.04
|
7.24±0.02
7.29±0.02
|
|
Base
excess
mMol/L
|
CT
LR
|
0.4±1
0.6±1.3
|
-9.0±2.8
-6.4±1.9
|
-10.8±3.5
-8.1±2.5
|
-12.2±3.2
-4.3±3.6
|
|
Bicarbonate
mEq/L
|
CT
LR
|
26.7±1.0
26.0±1.3
|
18.0±2.6
20.3±1.9
|
16.5±3.0
19.6±2.2
|
15.3±2.9
22.4±3.3
|
 |
Every animal
presented a hemodynamic and metabolic profile of severe hemorrhagic
shock. Significant and abrupt drops in mean arterial pressure, cardiac
output, O2 delivery, SvO2, base excess and bicarbonate levels were shown
(Fig. 1; Table 1). Eight dogs died before randomization, and were thereby
excluded. Animals from the CT group remained in severe shock throughout
the experiment. The LR group showed a gradual elevation in mean arterial
pressure which, at 40 minutes, was not different from baseline values.
However, in this group, two deaths occurred during the experimental
period, at 34 and 38 min. Therefore, values presented for 35 and 40
minutes in the LR group represent sample sizes of five and four animals,
respectively. LR infusion restored cardiac output to baseline values
(Figure 1) and was associated with partial restoration in O2 delivery,
SvO2. There were no significant improvements in pH, base excess and
bicarbonate levels after LR. Hemorrhage did not cause significant variations
in hemoglobin levels in the CT group during the experiment. In contrast,
there were significant decreases following LR treatment.
Iliac
artery puncture for retroperitoneal hemorrhage (n=22)
Baseline
measurements showed no significant differences between groups regarding
measured hemodynamic and metabolic parameters. Mean arterial pressure
remained stable following unilateral iliac artery lesion throughout
the experiment. In contrast, bilateral lesions induced an abrupt and
sustained decrease in mean arterial pressure, from 131.9±5.9
mmHg to 88.6±10.8 mmHg. Mean arterial pressure remained significantly
lower than that in the unilateral iliac lesion group throughout the
experiment (Fig. 2). Cardiac output and oxygen delivery presented rapid,
sustained and significant decreases after both unilateral or bilateral
iliac artery lesion. However the bilateral iliac artery lesion was associated
with a much greater reduction in both cardiac output and oxygen delivery
than the unilateral lesion throughout the experiment (Fig. 2, Table
2). Oxygen consumption was preserved following the unilateral lesion
until the last experimental moment, 120 minutes, when it became lower
than baseline values and similar to the bilateral lesion group. The
bilateral iliac lesion induced an abrupt and sustained decrease in oxygen
consumption throughout the experiment, which was significantly lower
than unilateral lesion group, except for the last experimental moment
(Table 2). Arterial base excess levels showed a progressive decrease
in both groups. Hemoglobin levels remained stable after unilateral iliac
lesion while bilateral lesions caused a significant decrease in hemoglobin
levels throughout the study (Table 2). Total blood loss into the retroperitoneal
space was greater after bilateral iliac lesion, 36.8±3.2 ml/Kg,
than following unilateral lesion, 25.1±3.4 ml/Kg.
Figure
2 - Mean arterial pressures (in mmHg) and cardiac index (in L/min/m2,
mean ± SEM), during 120 min of uncontrolled retroperitoneal hemorrhage
from an iliac artery tear for UL (unilateral iliac artery lesion, n=11)
and BL (bilateral iliac artery lesions, n=11) groups.

Table
2 - Oxygen delivery, oxygen consumption, hemoglobin and base deficit
levels (mean ± SEM) during 120 minutes of uncontrolled retroperitoneal
hemorrhage for UL (unilateral iliac artery lesion, n=11) and BL (bilateral
iliac arteries lesions, n=11) groups
 |
|
|
Group
|
Baseline
|
10
min
|
60
min
|
120
min
|
 |
|
O2
delivery
mLO2/min
|
UL
BL
|
559.9±47.1
444.4±36.5
|
417.2±68.8
187.8±25
|
412.7±53.4
192.5±20.3
|
335.6±44.7
175.3±19.4
|
|
O2
consumption
mLO2
/min/m2
|
UL
BL
|
130.6±14.6
127.8±14.2
|
119.9±17.9
81.9±8.3
|
134.1±15.5
94.4±10.3
|
105.1±8.9
94±9.5
|
|
Hemoglobin
g/dl
|
UL
BL
|
13.6±0.9
13±0.6
|
12.9±1
11.3±0.4
|
12.3±1
9.8±0.6
|
12.2±0.9
9.5±0.6
|
|
Base excess
mMol/L
|
UL
BL
|
-3.9±1.5
-5.5±1.0
|
-5.2±1.3
-8.9±1.0
|
-6.8±1.2
-11.8±1.6
|
-6.1±1.3
-13.1±2.0
|
 |
DISCUSSION
We presented
two distinct models of iliac artery lesions inducing predictable hemodynamic
responses and blood loss volumes, which may be useful to develop studies
in several areas of physiology and treatment of vascular trauma and
uncontrolled hemorrhage. A major controversy regarding prehospital treatment
of posttraumatic hypotension in victims ries concerns fluid resuscitation.2-5
Both models adequately simulated the clinical behavior of a penetrating
abdominal injury with an intraabdominal hemorrhage and an exclusive
retroperitoneal hemorrhage, such as observed in complex pelvic fractures.
In our model of uncontrolled intra-abdominal hemorrhage, induced by
an iliac arterial tear, we provide experimental evidence in support
of an antagonistic hypothesis, namely, that 20 minutes after trauma,
fluid resuscitation does promote hemodynamic benefits while no fluid
resuscitation is associated with low cardiac output and metabolic derangement.
Moreover, no increase in intra-abdominal bleeding followed either of
the fluid resuscitation regimens. It could be argued that treated animals
were not restored to baseline arterial pressure, thereby decreasing
the possibility of clot disruption and consequent rebleeding, which
is the basis for the hypotensive resuscitation concept.5 Two deaths
occurred before the end of the experiment after large volume resuscitation
only in LR group. These animals rank among the four highest blood losses
in the entire protocol, but the arteriotomy size was not different from
all other animals.
There are
limitations in our iliac artery tear model, as is also true for all
of the controlled and uncontrolled hemorrhage models. Clinical presentations
of trauma victims are complex, transport conditions vary, and prehospital
and emergency room protocols differ. Resuscitation tends to be an ongoing
process, while in our protocol animals where only observed for a short
period and received no surgical correction. Therefore, great caution
should be exercised when extrapolating our findings to the clinical
scenario. Our follow-up after treatment was deliberately very short:
we chose to finish our experimental protocol 40 minutes after the iliac
artery tear, in order to precisely measure blood loss within the abdominal
cavity. Our objective was to specifically address the ongoing controversy
on whether fluid resuscitation, during prehospital setting, increases
bleeding after a penetrating injury.2-5,14-15
A longer follow-up period, to include a survival evaluation, would have
jeopardized this objective, but is obviously required to further clarify
the key issue of fluid resuscitation in trauma. On the positive side,
a 2-3 mm iliac artery tear in a spontaneously breathing dog caused a
major hemorrhage which closely mimics a penetrating abdominal injury
affecting a large vessel. Eight dogs died before treatment, and were
excluded from the analysis. These animals presented rapid hypotension,
below the 20 mmHg mark, followed by cardiac arrest. The majority of
survivors also presented a rapid drop in mean arterial pressure to the
25 - 45 mmHg range, five minutes after the lesion, suggesting that most
of the bleeding occurs immediately. These findings show that our model
is adequate, since it is very similar to civilian series, in which several
victims sustaining iliac artery lesions die on their way to the hospital,
and most of the ones reaching the surgical theater are in frank hemorrhagic
shock from intra-abdominal bleeding.16,17
Transfemoral
bilateral iliac artery puncture showed to be a clinically relevant model
of uncontrolled retroperitoneal hemorrhage, which induces a blood loss
equivalent to 43% of the initial blood volume, moderate hypotension
and a marked decrease in cardiac output. This condition is frequently
observed in patients sustaining blunt trauma and pelvic fractures, in
whom mortality is high, largely due to associated lesions and retroperitoneal
bleeding contributing to shock.18,19
It is not known whether fluid resuscitation increases retroperitoneal
hemorrhage and clinically relevant models of retroperitoneal hematoma
are lacking. In our model, major hemodynamic and metabolic changes were
observed immediately after arterial punctures, without further derangement
throughout the experimental protocol. These data suggest that most of
the bleeding occurred within the first five minutes and hemorrhage was
severe enough to result in decompensation, since sustained hypotension,
low cardiac output and metabolic acidosis were observed. No intra-abdominal
bleeding was observed which indicates that clot formation, increase
in retroperitoneal space pressure and moderate hypotension effectively
avoided continuous blood loss. Therefore, our model is particularly
appropriate to evaluate controversies regarding fluid resuscitation
in the setting of uncontrolled hemorrhage. Current models of uncontrolled
hemorrhage do not conform to retroperitoneal related issues. Most of
them are clinically relevant to some forms of penetrating injuries,
with intra-abdominal hemorrhage. The only experimental model of retroperitoneal
hemorrhage that we are aware has no clinical relevance, since it was
produced by a direct injection of venous blood into the retroperitoneal
space, the volume and rate of blood infusion were determinated by the
researcher, the abdominal cavity was opened, and the integrity of parietal
peritoneum was compromised.11 Unilateral iliac artery puncture produced
a blood loss of 29% of the initial blood volume, resulting in a compensated
shock condition, with normal blood pressure and modest decreases in
cardiac output. This model may be useful to address questions regarding
conditions associated with a class II hemorrhage, according to ATLS
criteria.1
There are
limitations of this experimental model. Isolated iliac artery lesions,
bleeding solely to the retroperitoneal space is rarely observed clinically.
The lack of associated pelvic fracture and the impossibility to continuously
evaluate blood loss by the radioisotope technique allow us only to speculate
about the moment in which bleeding was greater. On the other hand, this
is an easily performed, highly reproducible model of uncontrolled retroperitoneal
hemorrhage. Although caution should be exercised when drawing clinical
implications from animal studies, our model, by inducing a moderate
hypotension and a severe low flow state, fits a large population of
patients sustaining pelvic fractures and contained retroperitoneal hematoma.
Thereby, it may be useful to address fluid resuscitation concerns, particularly
in patients sustaining head trauma, since secondary brain injury can
be developed by retroperitoneal hemorrhage induced hypotension. We conclude
that bilateral iliac artery puncture through the femoral arteries produce
a clinically relevant model of uncontrolled retroperitoneal hemorrhage,
with hypotension and low flow state, while an unilateral iliac artery
lesion causes a compensated shock state.
REFERENCES
1.
American College of Surgeons. Advanced Trauma Life Support Program
for Physicians. 6th ed. Chicago, 1997.
2.
Gross D, Landau EH, Assalia A, Krausz MM. Is hypertonic saline resuscitation
safe in "uncontrolled" hemorrhagic shock? J Trauma. 1988;28:751-6.
3.
Bickell WH, Bruttig SP, Wade CE. Hemodynamic responses to abdominal
aortotomy in the anesthetized swine. Circ Shock. 1989;28:321-32.
4.
Capone AC, Safar. P, Stezotski, W. Tisherman S, Peitzman A. Improved
outcome with fluid restriction in treatment of uncontrolled hemorrhagic
shock. J Am Coll Surg. 1995; 180:49-56.
5.
Bickell WH, Wall MJ, Pepe PE et al. Immediate versus delayed fluid
resuscitation for hypotensive patients with penetrating torso injuries.
N Engl J Med. 1994;331:1105-9.
6.
Bruscagin V, Poli de Figueiredo LF, Rasslan S, Varicoda EY, Rocha
e Silva M. Fluid resuscitation improves hemodynamics without increased
bleeding in a model of uncontrolled hemorrhage induced by an iliac
artery tear in dogs. J Trauma 2002;52(6): (in press) .
7.
Looser KG, Crombie HD. Pelvic fractures: An anatomic guide to severity
of Injury. Am J Surg 1976;132:638-42.
8.
Goins WA, Rodriguez A, Lewis J, Brathwaite CE, James E. Retroperitoneal
hemorrhage after blunt trauma. Surg Gynecol Obst 1992;174(4):281-90.
9.
Bosse MJ, Reinert CM. Pelvic Fractures. In: Retroperitoneal Trauma,
1st edn, SB Frame, NE McSwain, Thieme Medical Publishers, New York,
1992, pp. 173-192.
10.
Dalal SA, Burgess AR, Siegel JH, Young JW, Brumback RJ, Poka A, Dunham
CM, Gens D, Bathon H. Pelvic Fracture in multiple trauma: classification
by mechanism is the key to pattern of organ injury, resuscitative
requirements and outcome. J Trauma 1989;29(7):981-1000.
11.
Baylis SM, Lansing EH, Glas WW. Traumatic retroperitoneal hematoma.
Am J Surg 1962;103:477-80.
12.
Cruz Jr RJ, Perin D, Silva LE, Valério FB, Branco MC, Poli
de Figueiredo LF, Rocha e Silva M. Radioisotope blood volume measurement
in uncontrolled retroperitoneal hemorrhage induced by a transfemoral
iliac artery puncture. Injury 2001;32(1):17-21.
13.
Kowalsky RJ, Perry JR. In vivo Function Studies. In: Radiopharmaceuticals
in nuclear medicine practice, RJ Kowalsky JR Perry, Appleton and Lange,
Connecticut, 1987, pp 411-33.
14.
Bickell WH, Bruttig, SP, Millnamow GA, O'Benar J. The detrimental
effects of intravenous crystalloid after aortotomy in swine. Surgery.
1991;110(3):529-36.
15.
Kowalenko T, Stern S, Dronen S, Wang X. Improved outcome with hypotensive
resuscitation of uncontrolled hemorrhagic shock in a swine model.
J Trauma. 1992;33(3):349-53.
16.
Davis TP, Feliciano DV, Rozycki GS et al. Results with abdominal vascular
trauma in the modern era. Am Surg 2001;67:565-71.
17.
Asensio JA, Chahwan S, Hanpeter D et al. Operative management and
outcome of 302 abdominal vascular injuries. Am J Surg 2000;180:528-34.
18.
Selivanov V, Chi HS, Alverdy JC, Morris JA Jr, Sheldon GF. Mortality
in retroperitoneal hematoma. J Trauma 1984, 24:1022-7.
19.
Henao F, Aldrete JS. Retroperitoneal hematomas of traumatic origin.
Surg Gynecol Obst 1985;161:106-16.
|